The BBC: Obama Speech: An Analysis
An interesting and effective approach, if somewhat gimmicky. The BBC broke up the text of the speech into sections, and after each section inserted a “pop up” analysis from one of their commentators. It’s a good way to encourage the reading of the entire transcript. The annotations encourage a thoughtful review of the content. The analysis itself is uneven. I like the way Paul Reynolds, BBC world affairs correspondent, puts the president’s statements in the context of Obama’s policy positions. I found this helpful and thought-provoking. I did not have much use for his value-laden assessments, using language such as “romanticize” or “flatter.” This is wholly a matter of projecting on the part of Mr. Reynolds. He is not a psychologist. Grade: B+
Deutsche Welle: Obama speaks of new beginning between US and Muslim world
A very objective summary of the president’s remarks. No spin, no value judgment. Some excerpts from the speech. As a news report conveying the content of the remarks, DW did an excellent job. Someone who did not see the speech would understand the intent, the tone, and the impression left by the speech. Grade: A
